The New Zealand Knowledge Economy - A review of international methodologies for measuring the knowledge economy, and preliminary findings for New Zealand
APPENDIX TWO - THE CANTERBURY KNOWLEDGE ECONOMY.
The Knowledge Intensity of industries varies across the regions of New Zealand. Comparing results for Canterbury against the national average shows some interesting differences.
The industries with the highest levels of knowledge intensity (those with a K1 rating) are quite similar in Canterbury and New Zealand overall. The main differences are that Canterbury does not have a significant Government Administration industry, and the Canterbury Mining, Tobacco Product and Recorded Media industries having a higher than average skill level (although it must be noted that the these industries are quite small in Canterbury, combining to employee only 33 people).
The major differences in knowledge intensity between Canterbury and the national average occur in the composition of the K2 and K3 industries[26]. Nationally, the majority of Finance and Insurance sub industries (ANZSIC96 Division K) are coded with a K2 rating, while in Canterbury, most of these sub industries have a K3 rating. Nationally, most of the Finance and Insurance sub industries had a graduate employment rate of between 30 - 35%, while the corresponding figure for Canterbury was a step lower at between 15 - 25%. A table showing 3 digit ANZSIC96 industries by their knowledge intensity for both New Zealand and Canterbury is included at the end of this section.
The difference in qualification levels may be due to the majority of regional employment in the finance and insurance industries being in branch offices, with the assumption being that the more highly skilled jobs in these industries being located in the Head Offices, generally based in Auckland and Wellington.
This assumption is supported by the comparison of results between Canterbury and Wellington regions. Canterbury has one of the eight Finance and Insurance sub industries within the K1 and K2 categories (K751 Services to Finance and Investment is rated K2), while Wellington has seven of the eight Finance and Insurance sub industries within the K1 and K2 categories. This shows that Wellington employment in these industries is generally more highly qualified. Results at the two digit level show the same basic pattern.
While the knowledge intensity of these sub industries for Canterbury trail the national average, inter temporal analysis show recent improvement. Results from the Annual In Depth Regional report (AIDR) for Canterbury[27] show that employment and Hours worked in ANZSIC Division K (Finance and Insurance) grew faster than the New Zealand average between 2001 and 2006. Also, the share of university graduates in the Canterbury workforce has increased markedly in this industry between 2001 and 2006. On average, the share of graduates in the eight Finance and Insurance sub industries has grown by around 5% each, with 5 of the sub industries having a K4 rating in 2001, declining to only one K4 rating in 2006.
Canterbury, and in particular Christchurch City, has a well known Electronics cluster. It is interesting to note that the results for Canterbury and Christchurch City for both 'C283 Photographic and Scientific Equipment Manufacturing' and 'C284 Electronic Equipment Manufacturing' industries are marginally less skilled than the New Zealand average levels. This result was not expected and is certainly worthy of further discussion with stakeholders. One reason for lower than average qualification levels in the Canterbury electronics industries might be that there is a higher share of production line workers than product developers in Canterbury. Alternatively, the employment of the highly skilled staff in the Canterbury Electronics cluster may have been coded to industries other than the ones identified above.
| New Zealand | Canterbury |
|---|---|
| L781 Scientific Research | B142 Mining nec |
| L782 Technical Services | C219 Tobacco Product Manufacturing |
| L783 Computer Services | C243 Recorded Media Manufacturing and Publishing |
| L784 Legal and Accounting Services | L781 Scientific Research |
| M811 Government Administration | L782 Technical Services |
| M813 Foreign Government Representation | L783 Computer Services |
| N842 School Education | L784 Legal and Accounting Services |
| N843 Post School Education | M813 Foreign Government Representation |
| O864 Veterinary Services | N842 School Education |
| N843 Post School Education | |
| O864 Veterinary Services | |
| C242 Publishing | B110 Coal Mining |
| C243 Recorded Media Manufacturing and Publishing | C283 Photographic and Scientific Equipment Manufacturing |
| C283 Photographic and Scientific Equipment Manufacturing | C284 Electronic Equipment Manufacturing |
| C284 Electronic Equipment Manufacturing | D361 Electricity Supply |
| D362 Gas Supply | I661 Services to Road Transport |
| D370 Water Supply, Sewerage and Drainage Services | K751 Services to Finance and Investment |
| I661 Services to Road Transport | L785 Marketing and Business Management Services |
| J712 Telecommunication Services | M811 Government Administration |
| K731 Central Bank | M812 Justice |
| K733 Other Financiers | N841 Preschool Education |
| K734 Financial Asset Investors | N844 Other Education |
| K741 Life Insurance and Superannuation Funds | O861 Hospitals and Nursing Homes |
| K751 Services to Finance and Investment | O862 Medical and Dental Services |
| L773 Non-Financial Asset Investors | O863 Other Health Services |
| L785 Marketing and Business Management Services | P921 Libraries |
| M812 Justice | P922 Museums |
| N844 Other Education | P923 Parks and Gardens |
| O861 Hospitals and Nursing Homes | P924 Arts |
| O862 Medical and Dental Services | P925 Services to the Arts |
| O863 Other Health Services | Q961 Religious Organisations |
| P911 Film and Video Services | Q962 Interest Groups |
| P912 Radio and Television Services | |
| P921 Libraries | |
| P922 Museums | |
| P923 Parks and Gardens | |
| P924 Arts | |
| P925 Services to the Arts | |
| Q961 Religious Organisations | |
| Q962 Interest Groups | |
|
|
|
| B120 Oil and Gas Extraction | B151 Exploration |
| B151 Exploration | C242 Publishing |
| C218 Beverage and Malt Manufacturing | C254 Other Chemical Product Manufacturing |
| C253 Basic Chemical Manufacturing | D370 Water Supply, Sewerage and Drainage Services |
| C254 Other Chemical Product Manufacturing | G524 Recreational Good Retailing |
| D361 Electricity Supply | G525 Other Personal and Household Good Retailing |
| F461 Machinery and Equipment Wholesaling | I630 Water Transport |
| F472 Textile, Clothing and Footwear Wholesaling | J712 Telecommunication Services |
| F479 Other Wholesaling | K731 Central Bank |
| G525 Other Personal and Household Good Retailing | K732 Deposit Taking Financiers |
| I630 Water Transport | K733 Other Financiers |
| K732 Deposit Taking Financiers | K734 Financial Asset Investors |
| K742 Other Insurance | K741 Life Insurance and Superannuation Funds |
| K752 Services to Insurance | K742 Other Insurance |
| L771 Property Operators and Developers | L771 Property Operators and Developers |
| L772 Real Estate Agents | L772 Real Estate Agents |
| L786 Other Business Services | L773 Non-Financial Asset Investors |
| N841 Preschool Education | O871 Child Care Services |
| O871 Child Care Services | P911 Film and Video Services |
| P931 Sport | P912 Radio and Television Services |
| P932 Gambling Services | P931 Sport |
| P933 Other Recreation Services | |
[26] K2 Industries had between 25- 40% of their workforces as graduates, while K3 industries have between 15-25% of their workforces as graduates
[27] The Annual In Depth Regional report for Canterbury is available from the DoL website, here - http://www.dol.govt.nz/publications/lmr/regional/indepth/canterbury/index.asp.
