FOUNDATION SKILLS IN SEASONAL WORKPLACES Phase II Report December 2006
Appendix 3 Questions Used With Different Industry Groups
14.Workplace questionnaire
Section A - Workplace profile
Could we start by getting an overview of this company and how it operates?
a. Main activities/crop etc
b. History of company
c. Ownership, structure
d. Role of contractors
e. Links with industry, other key bodies
f. Union role
g. Markets/customers
h. Quality management systems
i. International market requirements
What are this company's products?
Section B - Workforce profile
Can you give me an idea of who works for this company (on this site only)?
a. (asked about numbers, positions, permanent vs. seasonal, ethnic background, ESOL, people who returned each season)
Do you use a contractor for seasonal workers?
a. Who?
b. How long have you be using this contractor?
How many would you classify in these groups?
a. Students/backpackers
b. Inexperienced temporary seasonal
c. workers with low motivation
d. Seasonal workers returning each season
e. "Professional" seasonal workers (follow the work)
f. Migrant workers
What employment arrangements are in place?
a. Hours of work/shifts
b. Overtime arrangements
c. Pay rates
d. Union involvement/collective agreement
e. What process do you use to induct new employees into the company
Section C - Workplace issues and developments
What are the main issues you are facing at present in this company?
What critical areas of wastage/non compliance matter to you at this company?
What are you trying to do about these issues?
1How typical are these issues for this industry?
Very typical ≤ Reasonably typical ≤ Unusual ≤
1Are you planning any changes or new procedures in future seasons that will affect the way work is done?
1Looking to the next 5 years, are there any other issues you see?
Section D - Workplace training
1What training is done "on the job"
a. For seasonal workers
b. For others
1Have you had any training programmes on-site over the past year?
a. Over the past 3 years?
b. Internal or external trainers used?
1Have any of your workers been involved in any training programmes with training providers over the past year/the past 3 years?
1Can you tell me who provides training in this area? Do any of these providers specialise in foundation skills?
Section E - Foundation skills
1How are work instructions given - in writing, orally?
1What speaking and listening do employees need to do?
1What reading do people need to do?
2What writing do employees need to do - forms etc?
2What maths do employees need to do - weighing, measuring, and calculating?
2What technology do employees need to use?
2What decision making/problem solving activities do employees have to complete?
2How big an issue are these for your company?
|
Foundation skill |
Major difficulties |
Moderate difficulties |
Minor difficulties |
No difficulties |
|
Reading |
||||
|
Writing |
||||
|
Spelling |
||||
|
Maths |
||||
|
Speaking (general) |
||||
|
English lang. |
Questions about team leaders and supervisors (for managers)
- How do supervisors/team leaders usually communicate with their staff?
- What reports and other documents do they have to write?
- What happens with health and safety/incident/accident reporting?
- What are the KPIs for supervisors and team leaders?
- How are supervisors/team leaders involved in managing the performance of staff?
- What technology do they have to use for their roles (e.g.: computers - email, spreadsheets, Word, company database, QMS, scanning?)
- Anything that team leaders/supervisors can't do that you think they should be able to do?
2What proportion of your workers in these categories do you think have significant difficulties?
|
Reading |
Writing |
Spelling |
Maths |
Speaking(general) |
Speaking English |
Using technology |
|
|
Supervisors |
|||||||
|
Office staff |
|||||||
|
Pickers |
|||||||
|
Packers |
|||||||
|
Pruners |
2Are there any particular groups of your workers that you see as having the most difficulties?
Section F - Possible solutions
2If you were going to run a foundation skills programme for your workers, how would you go about doing it?
2What are the key factors to making it work (including people)?
2What would be the biggest obstacles to running it successfully?
3If you were to run a foundation skills programme in your company, what types of worker do you think would be most interested in doing it?
a. And the least interested?
3(If don't see direct training for seasonal workers as a priority) What channel or vehicle would you use to make sure they get some training?
Section G - Questions for supervisors/team leaders
3Tell me about literacy issues in your department/area and how they are showing up.
3What is it that people in your department/area can't do that you think they should be able to do.
a. Extent of multi-skilling.
b. Extent of job coverage.
c. Involvement with technology.
d. Involvement with training.
e. Completion of literacy tasks up to company standards e.g. forms filled in full, calculations all correct.
3What is one thing that you would change in your department that would make your job easier?
3Barriers to literacy skill development (could be organisational or personal).
3Reception by others of possible programme.
3Are you planning any changes or new procedures in future seasons that will affect the way work is done?
3Any skill needs you have yourself?
14.Questionnaire for government department personnel
Department details:
Name of Department/Ministry:
Address:
Interviewee:
Phone: Fax: Email:
What involvement does your department have at the national and/or local level in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industries?
Has your department funded any research into foundation skills or foundation skill development programmes for workers in pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industries?
a. Which group? Pip ≤ Kiwi ≤ Wine ≤
Areas:
What about other horticulture sectors?
Or other seasonal workers?
a. Which groups of other seasonal workers?
b. What happened?
Are there any specific issues that these programmes have been aimed at?
a. Pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine workers
b. Other types of horticulture workers
c. Other seasonal workers
Are you aware of any training providers who teach foundation skills courses to people in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industries?
a. Yes ≤ No ≤
b. If yes, who?
What advice do you have for anyone trying to run foundation skills courses in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industry?
Any other comments?
14.Questionnaire for training provider personnel
Provider details:
Name of Provider:
Address:
Interviewee:
Phone: Fax: Email:
Main areas of training offered by company/organisation:
What involvement has your organisation had in training for the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industries?
What about other horticulture sectors?
Type of worker (permanent/supervisors):
a. Sector:
b. Type of worker (permanent/supervisors):
Or other seasonal workers?
a. Type of worker (permanent/seasonal/supervisors):
b. Sector:
What do you see as the key future skill demands for horticulture in Kiwifruit/pipfruit/wine sectors in the future?
a. for permanent staff?
Kiwi Pip Wine
b. for seasonal workers?
Kiwi Pip Wine
What do you see as the critical foundation skills in the wine/kiwifruit/pipfruit industries?
a. for horticulture workers generally
b. for other types of seasonal workers
Do you have plans to do anything to address these skills? If so, what?
Do you know of any training providers in this area who teach foundation skills courses?
a. Yes ≤ No ≤
b. If yes, who?
1Any comments on what they offer?
1What do you see as the key elements of running successful training courses in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industry?
1And the biggest issues for these sorts of courses?
1Do you see any opportunities for foundation skills development or other training in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industry? If so, what?
1Any other comments?
14.Questionnaire for industry association personnel
Association details
Name of Association:
Address:
Interviewee:
Phone: Fax: Email:
Can we start by looking at some facts and figures about your association?
a. How many members?
b. Distribution throughout New Zealand?
c. What types of operations do they run?
Do you have labour force employment figures for permanent and seasonal workers in pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industry?
a. Locally?
b. Nationally?
What are the critical issues (e.g. wastage/non compliance/competition) that matter to your members?
a. Industry issues
b. Worker/staffing issues
What do you see as the key skill demands for horticulture in your sector in the future?
a. for permanent staff?
b. for seasonal workers?
What are the most important foundation skills in your industry (wine/kiwifruit/pipfruit)? How important do you think these skills are?
a. for horticulture workers generally?
b. for seasonal workers?
Do you know if workers have issues with their foundation skills in your industry? Is so, what issues do they have?
a. for horticulture workers generally?
b. for seasonal workers
Do your members understand about the importance of foundation skills to other skill development?
What evidence do you think your member growers/operators would need to convince them of the value of foundation skills programmes in the pipfruit/kiwifruit/wine industry?
a. for horticulture workers generally?
b. for seasonal workers?
What foundation skills training providers are you aware of?
a. on job/off job courses
1What do you see as the key barriers to foundation skills training taking place?
a. for permanent workers?
b. for seasonal workers?
1How could these barriers be overcome?
1Any other comments?
14.Questionnaire for Horticulture ITO personnel
Section A: Questions for Norm Miller only
Can you explain what the seasonal workers' programme that you are involved with is all about?
Is it related to training agreements/unit standards/ITO?
What is the ITO learning from this programme?
Section B: Questions for any Horticulture ITO staff interviewed
What training is available throughout the country for workers in wine, kiwifruit, pipfruit industries at present?
a. for horticulture workers generally?
b. for seasonal workers?
What do you think about seasonal workers and training generally? Are there training issues? Are there ways it could be done?
What are the critical issues (e.g. wastage/non compliance) for your clients?
a. Pipfruit
b. kiwifruit
c. Wine
What are the opportunities and drawbacks for training in the pipfruit, grape and kiwifruit industries?
a. Pipfruit
b. Wine
c. Kiwifruit
Does the ITO have plans to do more with seasonal workers?
a. If so, what?
b. If not, do you know why not?
Do you think the Hort ITO sees foundation skills for the industry as a:
a. A major issue needing to be addressed ≤
b. A major issue, too difficult to address ≤
c. A minor issue ≤
d. Not an issue at all ≤
What specific types of foundation skills need to be addressed (in order of importance)?
a. Kiwifruit
b. Pipfruit
c. Wine
d. Permanent
e. Seasonal
Any other comments?
14.Questionnaire for contractors
Contractor details
Name of Contractor:
Address:
Liaison Person:
Phone: Fax: Email:
Contracts to:
Can we start by finding out some facts and figures about your company.
a. What sort work does your company do?
b. How many staff do you employ?
c. How many are permanent?
d. How many seasonal workers do you have?
e. How many orchards/vineyards do you contract to?
What kind of work do your staff do?
How do you train your staff?
a. Seasonal workers
b. Supervisors/permanent staff
What key issues (e.g.: wastage/non compliance) matter to you at this company?
What key issues (e.g.: wastage/non compliance) matter to the companies you contract to?
What are you trying to do about the key issues?
What foundation skill requirements are there?
a. for seasonal workers
b. for others (especially supervisors)
What are the gaps - what can't they do?
a. for seasonal workers
b. for others (especially supervisors)
Where do your seasonal workers come from?
a. Students/backpackers
b. Inexperienced temporary seasonal workers with low motivation
c. Seasonal workers returning each season
d. "Professional" seasonal workers (follow the work)
e. Migrant workers
1Any other comments?
